CO129-514-6 Question of legality of sale of water to Tai Koo Sugar Refining Co. Ltd.- from... 6-12-1928 - 23-12-1929 — Page 14

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

FROM BURCHELLS,

14

2,

DATE 17th August, 1929.

LETTER TOSir John isley, K.C.M.G., K.C. SHEET NO.

C.B.

"Attorney-General could apply for an injunction but there

seems to be no actual decided case to this effect."

Counsel then deal with the results of obtaining an

injunction and it is on this point that I differ with them.

I do not think the Company could obtain leave to alter its

Memorandum of Association to enable it to undertake a totally

new and distinct business from that for which it was incorpora-

ted. The objects stated in its Memorandum were the carrying

on of the trade or business of sugar cleaning and refining,

the purchase and sale of sugar and sugar producing articles,

the making and dealing in lump and other kinds of sugar, and

manufacturers of and dealers in sugar. The objects of the

Company therefore are extremely limited and in none of the reported

cases have I been able to find a case in which a Company formed

for an exclusive purpose such as this one, is allowed to amend

its Memorandum to enable it to take up a totally different

business.

The other suggestion of counsel was that the Company

might reconstruct, but I do not think a reconstruction is what

counsel meant, but they must have meant the incorporation of a

new company and the transfer to it of the existing Company's

property and rights, but I am of opinion that if they sought

to get over the difficulty in this way the Government would be

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.